Additional Resources for Analyzing Arguments

Because we know that "born digital" arguments are being created all the time, we invite teachers to share their best examples of student work (and the lesson ideas that supported them) here so we can all benefit from seeing exemplary web-based texts, infographics, videos, social media, and sample assessment tools. ~ Kristen and Troy

Arguments in Web-Based Texts (e.g., Blogs)

Please link to your students' work here (and also include your name and Twitter handle)

Arguments in Infographics

Please link to your students' work here (and also include your name and Twitter handle)

Arguments in Video

Please link to your students' work here (and also include your name and Twitter handle)

Arguments in Social Media

@VMattPV (Valerie Mattessich, Pascack Valley High School)

Link to social media analysis assignment
Video 1 and video 2 of me presenting this lesson to my class
Student work samples

MINDFUL remixed (have you created a different version of our MINDFUL framework? Please share it here.)

Assessing Digital Arguments

Please link to your students' work here (and also include your name and Twitter handle)

Professional Mentor Texts for Digital Argument

Please link professional examples (and also include your name and Twitter handle)

Resources for Thinking About Evidence

Mathematica Policy Research Report "Understanding Types of Evidence: A Guide for Educators"

Handouts from our book chapter, "Reconsidering Evidence in Real World Arguments"

How Does the Evidence Contribute to the Conversation? (Doc file for Blank Template)
How Does the Evidence Contribute to the Conversation? (PDF with Sample Response)